Template Stacks

STEP 1

Stack for testing on skycell with good target already selected
Before produce all the difference stack-stack it would be probably useful to test the ppsub on a small number of stacks. On MD03 skycel 043 the Harvard/JHU PS1 Group found some SN candidates. Using good images for this skycel, we could test ppsub and the photometry of psphot.

MD03

g skycell.043 stack.

r skycell.043 stack.39693

i skycell.043 stack.36944

z skycell.043 stack.

STEP 2

I'm selecting good stacks looking the following 4 parameters in the unconvolved stacks: average fhwm Minimum; average fhwm Major; average moment along xx; average momentum along yy.

Once a good night is selected in each filter, I checked 3-4 skycells by eyes and run ppSub using these images as template. (any suggestion how to improve the selection of the templates is welcomed).

Here are all the steps I'm doing:

• Download all new stacks in the archive
  

• Run psphot on unconvolved images
  

• Compare the following parameters from cmf files:
  

PSF magnitudes vs aperture magntude

moment along x vs moment along y

minimum fwhm vs major fwhm

COMMENTS:

the unconvolved images have more detections (but probably several of them are not real) the FWHM of the objects is degraded in the convolved image (probably too much in some skycells) To investigate the quality of stacks and select good templates, I used the fwhm and moments values of the unconvnolved images.

The choice of the unconvolved images to investigate the fwhm and moment variation is because in the convolved images the fwhm and moments are all degraded at similar values.

The average values for each skycell is computed rejecting at 3 sigma (5 iterations)

• I'm comparing the values of these parameters in each filters and each field
  

• taking a look by eyes some of the skycells of the best epochs, I choose the best templates
  

some epochs with small fwhm and moments (in principle good templates) seem to be masked too much

Good nights from which we can probably take the template stacks are reported below:

MD02

FILTER JD stacks.image.ID

g 55191 40790-40893

r 55188 44942-45045

i 55180 39135-39238

z 55096 31535-31604

MD03

FILTER JD stacks images

g

r 55207 41983-42082 (both good)

r 55183 39667-39770 (both good)

i

z

MD04

FILTER JD stacks images

g

r

i

z

• Finally, I'm testing ppSub with the templates selected
  

STEP 3

The choice of one night as template in each filter is in principle good, but for some skycells is not working:
For example: the a good r filter observation of MD03 is the one of JD=55207. It gives very good subtraction for some skycell (eg skycell 066) but there are during the same night other skycell not useful (eg skycell 102). In that case I would suggest to use different night as template for different skycell. In Figure skycell 066 and 102 for 2 good nights.

Probably it will be necessary to select for different skycell, different nights (as template)

MD03
skycell.066 stack.42029 JD.55207

skycell.090 stack.42052 JD.55207

skycell.102 stack.39714 JD.55183

skycell.043 stack.39693 JD.55183

.........